AmberCutie's Forum
An adult community for cam models and members to discuss all the things!

thoughts dick rating 🍆🥇

  • ** WARNING - ACF CONTAINS ADULT CONTENT **
    Only persons aged 18 or over may read or post to the forums, without regard to whether an adult actually owns the registration or parental/guardian permission. AmberCutie's Forum (ACF) is for use by adults only and contains adult content. By continuing to use this site you are confirming that you are at least 18 years of age.

Do you enjoy giving/receiving dick ratings?

  • Yeh

    Votes: 10 16.7%
  • Neh

    Votes: 31 51.7%
  • Meh

    Votes: 19 31.7%

  • Total voters
    60

AudriTwo

Cam Model
Jul 25, 2014
8,457
31,673
293
Twitter Username
@audritwo
Streamate Username
audritwo

*warning because horny men are notorious for being illiterate or not well*

NO DICK PICS

  • This isn't a thread asking models what they think about your genitals.
  • No model here cares about that unless you are paying them.
  • Do not message models replying in this thread unless you are asking for their link to pay for that interaction.
  • If any penises are posted, you have given me consent to photoshop them into a phallic-looking pokemon if Amber doesn't delete it first.

---
Dick rating topics have popped up in several threads throughout the years, and might as well create a thread on this topic. Recently we derailed the annoying model thread with our thoughts on the subject, but not to derail any further because we want to talk about penises. Curious about getting members' perspectives as well.

I personally don't like doing them. I think it can contribute to toxic masculinity, but at the same time, I see how much people like them. It's a conundrum though because I don't want to cause any hurt feels. I have had members go off the rails if I tell them something about their penis that makes them self-conscious. I always try to ask what type of rating they want- be honest, or what they want to hear. I'm super sad and tired of having men with perfectly normal-looking penises ask me if they are good enough.
 

AmberCutie

ACF Owner & Admin. (I don't work for CB.)
Staff member
Cam Model
Mar 1, 2010
28,296
4
119,412
0
AmberLand (Seattle, WA)
Twitter Username
@amberlynnegirl
MFC Username
AmberCutie
ManyVids URL
https://www.manyvids.com/Profile/1000458969/AmberCutie/
From a member’s perspective, I’ve never been tempted to ask for a model’s perspective on my member.

Not my thing, but I can understand why some guys might be into it.
The way I see it, the only people who ask for ratings are:

  • Uneasy about their dick size, but kinda think they're OK size, and need reassurance
  • Know they have an itty bitty dick and LOVE humiliation fetish stuff about it
  • Have an inflated ego because they think it's HUGE and want someone to confirm
So... just average normal people probably aren't into it. Because they don't have any of the above issues. (Yes, they're issues. In their heads.)
 
Nov 12, 2018
32
55
21
The way I see it, the only people who ask for ratings are:

  • Uneasy about their dick size, but kinda think they're OK size, and need reassurance
  • Know they have an itty bitty dick and LOVE humiliation fetish stuff about it
  • Have an inflated ego because they think it's HUGE and want someone to confirm
So... just average normal people probably aren't into it. Because they don't have any of the above issues. (Yes, they're issues. In their heads.)
Yup, pretty much. I dislike them. A lot. It gave me anxiety the one time I did it and the result was an astounding meh. You can google statistically average penis and find like a billion results that look just like mine. I tend to avoid wheels/games where dick ratings are "prizes".
 
  • Like
Reactions: Diana_Devil

GothHostess

Cam Model
Aug 12, 2019
201
436
31
Slytherin Common Room
Twitter Username
@ItsGothHostess
I only do them as part of SPH, and I always talk about it first to make sure they understand what they're getting in to. I don't do dick ratings outside of that. I suppose it's not really even a true dick rating when it's part of SPH, because I would never give it a positive rating (even if it's a nice dick) since it would completely destroy the fantasy.
 
Apr 21, 2020
592
1,357
31
The way I see it, the only people who ask for ratings are:

  • Uneasy about their dick size, but kinda think they're OK size, and need reassurance
  • Know they have an itty bitty dick and LOVE humiliation fetish stuff about it
  • Have an inflated ego because they think it's HUGE and want someone to confirm
So... just average normal people probably aren't into it. Because they don't have any of the above issues. (Yes, they're issues. In their heads.)

I wonder if some guys are into it because they just enjoy showing their dicks to random women, and asking for a rating is an excuse to do it. And the rating is basically just a receipt (confirmation that the woman looked at it).
 

EliMarie717

Cam Model
Dec 19, 2019
4,637
9,591
81
Twitter Username
@EliMarie717
Streamate Username
EliMarie717
ManyVids URL
https://www.manyvids.com/Profile/328205/EliMarie717/
Clips4Sale URL
https://www.clips4sale.com/studio/92217/marie717

AmberCutie

ACF Owner & Admin. (I don't work for CB.)
Staff member
Cam Model
Mar 1, 2010
28,296
4
119,412
0
AmberLand (Seattle, WA)
Twitter Username
@amberlynnegirl
MFC Username
AmberCutie
ManyVids URL
https://www.manyvids.com/Profile/1000458969/AmberCutie/
I wonder if some guys are into it because they just enjoy showing their dicks to random women, and asking for a rating is an excuse to do it. And the rating is basically just a receipt (confirmation that the woman looked at it).
I still feel that the need for that kind of attention to their phallus is a bit of an issue.
 

EliMarie717

Cam Model
Dec 19, 2019
4,637
9,591
81
Twitter Username
@EliMarie717
Streamate Username
EliMarie717
ManyVids URL
https://www.manyvids.com/Profile/328205/EliMarie717/
Clips4Sale URL
https://www.clips4sale.com/studio/92217/marie717
I still feel that the need for that kind of attention to their phallus is a bit of an issue
Definitely, if consent hasn't been established first. The sheer vast numbers of unsolicited dick pics that are sent, in general, are an issue. I would imagine the non-consent part in and of itself gets some of them off. Like the typical guy in the park w a trench coat type image that comes to mind.

Tongue ratings are not a thing, why? Seems like those would make a lot more sense.

They've implemented a feature on SM where images come in blurred. So now they can't do that anymore, which is great. So ew to get unasked for dick pics in the inbox, at random times. But also ew to get unasked for face pics, asking for dinner dates, meet-ups etc. Which also happens. Now we never have to see any of it, unless we actually want to these days.
 
Oct 9, 2021
2
0
0
miami
hi everyone. very new here. not an interest that ever evolved for me. Also, isn't this a little like asking your mom if you look good for the first school day of the year? She isn't going to admit your haircut was a mistake and your straight body is wearing a shirt that screams screams GAY . Unless your mom knows you like being a dirty little jon denver lookin trash bag .
 

CallMeMaria

Cam Model
Dec 1, 2018
269
506
61
MFC Username
CallMeMaria
Streamate Username
Blodieandbeast
Chaturbate Username
CallMeMaria
I dont mind giving a dick rating, for appropriate tokens. I dont see the thrill, its just my opinion and I tend not to be too nice. I totally would never pay for someone for a tit rating for example!

"yeah, its definitely not the biggest I have seen, nor the smallest. Good head, not enough girth for my liking, could have shaved your balls better. Its a 6 out of 10 for me."

Its almost like a report sheet at a dog show - very clinical and unemotive. Maybe that's not what they want when they pay for a dick rating...? 🤷‍♀️
 
Feb 6, 2021
71
113
6
sweetstrawberryruth.com
Twitter Username
@RuthStrawberry
I simply use neutral, and statement of fact phrases.

I look for something I can talk about, and encourage him with his wank.

I did not actually know what dick rating was for a while, then read about it on forums and really got into it after that. I will now incorporate this into a show. Do not misunderstand though I do call a spade-a-spade, and often call myself 'fantasy' destroyer but only when appropriate.
 
Mar 27, 2020
159
282
31
I'm a bit on the shy side, so I would never do it. But then again it would be the same as showing my face; I just don't like showing myself to someone I don't know. A model that I tipped well, repeatedly asked me to show it but I just couldn't bring myself to it.
But maybe it's as Amber said it; Average people have no need for it. I'm average in everything. I'm not a stud but don't consider myself ugly either. I don't need no flattering, confirmation or humiliation.
 
Nov 12, 2017
3,148
2
3,386
113
34
UK
Twitter Username
@brettm1987
The way I see it, the only people who ask for ratings are:

  • Uneasy about their dick size, but kinda think they're OK size, and need reassurance
  • Know they have an itty bitty dick and LOVE humiliation fetish stuff about it
  • Have an inflated ego because they think it's HUGE and want someone to confirm
So... just average normal people probably aren't into it. Because they don't have any of the above issues. (Yes, they're issues. In their heads.)



I will admit, I was the first one for my whole life until my ex convinced me to measure it.
A fact is, from a birdseye view, the penis to the guy looks smaller than it is, so it gives that impression of being tiny. So my whole life I thought I was well below average, so reluctantly I did measure (I had never ever been tempted to before she asked) mine, and to be honest, I am glad I did because it is normal/average. But I don't care or need everyone else to give reassurance for this.

I think also what has helped me is the fact I do listen to ladies (on the sites, on here, etc) about you not giving a shit about huge ones. So for a while now, I have been perfectly fine, happy, etc
 

AudriTwo

Cam Model
Jul 25, 2014
8,457
31,673
293
Twitter Username
@audritwo
Streamate Username
audritwo
I still feel that the need for that kind of attention to their phallus is a bit of an issue.
totes. i kinda look at it how i was with my boobs. when i was in my teens and early 20's lots of people in my life were constantly bringing up or tease that i have a flat chest. it fucked with me so bad. super self-conscious. any person i was with sexually i had to know their thoughts on them for reassurance that they like them. i mentioned to an ex im glad he likes my boobs after he said he liked them. he replied "meh, i do wish they were bigger. like your best friend's d cups." 😒 thanks 20-year-old man. therapy helped me learn to be more confident and accepting of my body and to tune out the nobodies who want to inappropriately comment on my chest size.

most porn is big dicks and most men, unfortunately, get their sexual education from it. we all know how porn can create false expectations. i think porn also creates a warped idea of what bodies should look like. this goes by any gender. throughout the years you have seen more different bodies of female-presenting folk in porn instead of that standard "porn look" that was big in the '90s-'00s. which is great. men not so much- still chiseled and big dicks. i don't know any porn stars with a dad bod with an average penis.
 

AudriTwo

Cam Model
Jul 25, 2014
8,457
31,673
293
Twitter Username
@audritwo
Streamate Username
audritwo
more thoughts:

you see men with uncircumcised penises ask if we like or our thoughts on it. even want to be shamed for not getting snipped. when in reality, uncircumcised penises are what penises should look like. most western societies have been conditioned to circumcise at birth for some outdated reasons. (i believe circumcision is genital mutilation. you are making lifetime changes to a newborn who cannot consent.)

funny but informative video on male circumcision in the west.
 

rylarosexo

Cam Model
Mar 5, 2020
646
2,034
31
I personally don’t mind dick ratings. I even created a dick rating dry erase board with different categories and notes. They can pay an extra for me to send them a pic of their overall rating.

I think when someone asks for a dick rating, they’re opening up themselves that models honesty. I am not one to stroke egos and am brutally honest, so I ask in advance prior to the show if that’s what they really want. I am never cruel or degrading about my ratings though. I don’t like how that effects their mental health. Weirdly enough many of my dick rating sessions have turned into sex education or sex tips.

That said though, I find a lot of guys that do dick ratings are looking for a few things:
  • Validation
  • Humiliation (SPH, cuckolding, etc.)
  • Ego boost
  • Curiosity of several woman think of their dick etc.
I find a lot of humor in it when guys who have big dicks think it’s god’s greatest gift to me. There is such a thing as too big for me. So I take that opportunity to humble them. Bigger isn’t better.

My biggest pet peeve when I rate them is when they ask if I would suck or fuck their dicks. The answer to any and all dicks, no matter the rating or size, “No.
 

thinkinboutit

Cam Model
Aug 22, 2019
1,294
2,908
51
First off all THANK YOU for this thread, this is a subject I think about a lot!

I find dick rates frustrating. Everything I'm about to say here is based on my own personal experience and hopefully does not apply to everyone.

I always ask them to specify if they want honest, gentle, or brutal review. If they say honest (almost all do) I tell them they can't get mad if they don't like what I have to say. Even though I make efforts not to be mean (unless asked) most will leave. If I want the show to keep going, I'm put in a position where I can't be completely honest.

Its unfair to ask someone with a vested ($) interest in not disappointing to give "honest" feedback. If you want me to praise your dick and tell you it looks great, then SAY THAT. Maybe it ruins the fantasy if I'm "in" on it, so they have to keep asking models to be "honest" until they find one who will give a 5/5.

If they are self conscious about how their dick looks, it seems unhealthy to ask someone to either a) pick it apart or b) flatter dishonestly. In that case, maybe a qualified mental health professional should be consulted to reach a place where penis shape/size isn't so crucial. Totally agree with what others have said RE penis obsession and men's self esteem. For example, I have a slight preference for uncut. I don't say that during the "honest" dick review in case dude has a circumcision complex and it messes him up to hear that.

-today's overthinking brought to you by strong coffee



Edit: I like @rylarosexo 's approach a lot :)
 

Danigirl

Cam Model
Jan 16, 2019
1,805
6,824
83
I used to give dick ratings for $$ but I stopped after I got one that made me want to vomit. Looked like he had deep blackheads all over the scrotum and bottom of the shaft. It was a sad looking penis by itself without the blackheads and it was below average but when I asked if he wanted honest, humiliation etc he didn't want humiliation. I think he wanted validation that he was fine and I wanted to refer him to a Dr. My rules now are don't be a dick don't send a dick. I do c2c with members I know or who have tipped a lot and aren't assholes.
 

KMH

Cam Model
Mar 17, 2018
441
1,089
73
Sweden
Twitter Username
@certifiedhips
Streamate Username
certifiedhips
A long time ago, I'd asked a member about how it was like to receive dick ratings. He was honest and said it was pretty "middle of the road;" a model would either give him 7-8/10's or "go overboard" on how perfect it was. He understood it was all a fantasy but iirc, he wasn't sure how to feel about dick rating in general.

I'm not sure how I'd feel either. It's definitely an intimate thing to show someone a nude, especially if you know someone you find attractive will see it.. but ultimately, if you're asking for someone's opinion while handing them money, of course they're going to be nice about it.
So I can understand that the satisfaction in that might be muddy for someone who's not looking for either sph or worship, but just finds the idea hot that someone they find hot will see it.
 
Apr 7, 2013
204
333
143
The way I see it, the only people who ask for ratings are:

  • Uneasy about their dick size, but kinda think they're OK size, and need reassurance
  • Know they have an itty bitty dick and LOVE humiliation fetish stuff about it
  • Have an inflated ego because they think it's HUGE and want someone to confirm
So... just average normal people probably aren't into it. Because they don't have any of the above issues. (Yes, they're issues. In their heads.)
I don't fit any of those. I'm pretty sure I'm average and I like my dick. It's nothing special. The only thing that's special about it is that its mine. I have zero interest in showing my dick to someone who isn't interested in seeing it either. I'm most definitely not looking to be humiliated. The funniest and best rating I ever got was, "if you looked up the word penis in the dictionary, you'd find a picture of yours" or something like that. Nah, for me it's an added level of permission and intimacy, if that makes sense. Like, I'm masturbating to someone who's seen me rather than someone who's totally removed from me. I don't get them often and I like to feel out how they view/approach dick ratings first and I would never ask if they aren't on offer.
 

Marceline

Cam Model
Aug 11, 2017
1,708
7,032
113
Don't like them and don't offer them. It honestly just makes me uncomfortable looking at random penises. Probably because it's pretty rare for me to see one and be like "Hey, that's a nice looking dick". And when there is one I like to look at, it's generally because it's attached to someone I'm attracted to. So I don't think I could give anyone a good rating. I could probably do SPH ratings, but honestly, I get burnt out super fast these days when interacting with members, so I don't really offer anything interactive aside from like, custom videos.
 

melanieoncam

Cam Model
Sep 18, 2010
565
1,468
143
I don't like doing them but do it when it's slow (dont really wanna see a random dick for a few bucks) but it occurred to me maybe I'm not charging enough. I'm curious what price range some are charging?

Sometimes I make them go private for it so that often they end up staying for a full session.
 

EliMarie717

Cam Model
Dec 19, 2019
4,637
9,591
81
Twitter Username
@EliMarie717
Streamate Username
EliMarie717
ManyVids URL
https://www.manyvids.com/Profile/328205/EliMarie717/
Clips4Sale URL
https://www.clips4sale.com/studio/92217/marie717
I'm curious what price range some are charging?
I say 15 GOLD to send one pic via DM. And all I feel obliged to give for that is an actual numerical rating, and a sentence or two.

Otherwise my per minute rate for at least a 2 minute private. I just raised my rates so that would be at least $18 for them, which translates to about $6 for me. Wow... I need to raise my rates for it too!
 

EliMarie717

Cam Model
Dec 19, 2019
4,637
9,591
81
Twitter Username
@EliMarie717
Streamate Username
EliMarie717
ManyVids URL
https://www.manyvids.com/Profile/328205/EliMarie717/
Clips4Sale URL
https://www.clips4sale.com/studio/92217/marie717
I always trip myself up by not taking into account that I only get 35%. I'm trying to learn to see it from my POV and not theirs, financially.
 

AudriTwo

Cam Model
Jul 25, 2014
8,457
31,673
293
Twitter Username
@audritwo
Streamate Username
audritwo
I don't like doing them but do it when it's slow (dont really wanna see a random dick for a few bucks) but it occurred to me maybe I'm not charging enough. I'm curious what price range some are charging?

Sometimes I make them go private for it so that often they end up staying for a full session.
they need to take me to exclusive. that can send me a photo instead of c2c, and i will open it once they start the show.
 

rylarosexo

Cam Model
Mar 5, 2020
646
2,034
31
I don't like doing them but do it when it's slow (dont really wanna see a random dick for a few bucks) but it occurred to me maybe I'm not charging enough. I'm curious what price range some are charging?

Sometimes I make them go private for it so that often they end up staying for a full session.
I don’t charge anything upfront. But I’ve managed to turn what was a 2 min dick rating into 10+ min on c2c in exclusive only to make it worthwhile. I don’t particularly care for pics, and if they prefer pics then I ask that send me several different angels and a nut shot too.

I ask them to give me certain angles, upclose, side view, etc. I also rate on lot of categories that even include cum shot. After it’s all said, I add up the score on my whiteboard and offer to send them a pic of their “report card” for an additional 10 gold and it’s been good so far.