mynameisbob84 said:
It's not actually as impressive as it initially seems once you realise they're just transposing all these songs to the same key, at which point the chords they're playing become almost inconsequential
THIS x a million.
I have a pet peeve about this, because when this came out every dickhead in the world kept playing it and being like 'Oh people are such sheep, they only like the same commercial music with the same chords blahblah'
But it's like...so? People have been using and reusing and recycling and sampling the same melodies, riffs, harmonies and chords throughout the history of music.
Take folk songs, for example. A lot of folk songs are ancient, but still sung, or well known and loved by millions of people. They are often the most simple songs ever. And there is often about 20 different songs with the exact same melody.
Most Bob Dylan songs use the same 4 or 5 chords, and he made some of the most beautiful songs ever written. (In my opinion
)
There are only so many chords. And so many chords that actually sound GOOD together. And there is an insane amount of music being made all over the world. You think that everyone should always come up with something ENTIRELY original?
Don't get me wrong, I'm glad that there are experimental musicians out there, and I love me some Mars Volta and Tool and love electronic music producers like Daedelus who are really trying to produce their own new sound, not be predictable.
But...really some experiential music is just BAD. Just noise. Because they are trying so hard to be 'original'...they forgot to make it listenable.
I'd prefer to just listen to the 'boring' and 'unoriginal' F G C F of
:twocents-02cents: